Monday, July 5, 2021

The Wisdom of the Sopranos Part 47 (Season 4, Episode 9 Whoever Did This)

 There are two separate story lines in this episode.  

This episode starts with Uncle Jr.'s continuing trial.  It seems has found an out by faking dementia.  The only thing is, he's not really faking it.  It ends with the brightness of a new day after Tony finally takes care of Ralph.

Uncle Jr. falls down the stairs at the courthouse and is taken to the hospital.  Tony decides to exploit this and claim Uncle Jr. has dementia.  If true it would cause a mistrial or would lead to a dismissal of the case.  However, although it's not evident to Tony and Uncle Jr.'s associates his mental state is diminished.  When they started coaching Uncle Jr. on how to answer questions at one point, they asked him what his name was.  The look on his face was one of complete confusion and a realization that he did not know how to answer.  Sometimes dementia happens so slowly that others fail to notice until too late.  It is like that with a lot of things that happen slowly.

Ralph's son (who I must say was never mentioned before and is added to create a convenient storyline) was hurt playing with a friend with arrows.  Rosalie comes to the hospital and Ralph apologies to her for not understanding what she was going through when Jackie Jr. was killed.  This is a true and wise statement.  No one knows what it is like when you lose someone.  Even if they say they understand, they don't.  How can they?  You can demonstrate sympathy but it's really not a good idea to tell someone you understand what they are going through.  You do not.  We are all too complex with different experiences that it is impossible to understand. 

Ralph goes to the priest.  He tells Ralph that God is merciful and there is a purpose to all things.  The priest talks about the suffering of Jesus on the cross.  The priest knows that Ralph is a mobster.  Another "devil" and he quotes from the song sympathy for the devil, "And I was 'round when Jesus Christ had his moment of doubt and pain".

Tony is forced comfort Ralph even though he really shouldn't have to. It’s not a role Tony is good at.  He lacks empathy.  Which is what makes him a good sociopath.  Except when it comes to animals.  Tony's favorite horse, Pie-O-My has to be put down after a terrible barn fire.  Tony goes to Ralph to tell him and it is apparent that Ralph arranged for the accident.  When Tony asks Ralph right out if he did Ralph wouldn’t look into Tony’s eyes.  Tony figures Ralph was involved, and Tony goes into a rage and a fight ensues with Tony eventually killing Ralph.  

Ralph’s death was a long time coming.  Tony has intolerance for harming animals.  Perhaps they remind him of his children and their innocence.  Maybe they give him the love he feels he is missing from his children.  Tony tried to connect with Anthony Jr. but he ignores his father.  It was an extremely uncomfortable scene.  At the end of this episode Tony is at the Bada-Bing after a night of cleaning up after disposing of Ralph.  Before he walks out, he sees a picture of the young woman that Ralph killed because she was pregnant with his child.  Another lost, innocent victim.  

Tony walks out to a new day…


No comments:

Post a Comment